Hmmm, yeah this episode is extremely underrated.
Even though there is a LOT of bad writing and acting at parts. I think the good over wins the bad.
I love the origami parts and the big 'twist' at the end. I absolutely love that scene when Michelle confronts Tony. It's actually one of my favorite scenes of Season 1.
For some reason, people have always hated the Reincarnation episodes, yet I have always liked them. They're not the best, in terms of writing. but the theme really does interest me,
I'm gonna give it a THREE star, but if the writing were a little more consistent i'd give it FOUR.