This film is about a veteran taking matters into his own hands when his son, who returned recently from Iraq, disappeared mysteriously.
"In the Valley of Elah" captivated me throughout the film. Both Tommy Lee Jones and Charlize Theron gave very good performances. I was a little disappointed to see Susan Sarandon's role being so small, but Sarandon did show her acting skills in the short amount of time allocated to her.
The plot is a hybrid of crime thriller and emotional drama. The balance is done well, and I kept wanting more of the plot to unfold. As to the backdrop of the story, Mike Deerfield need not to have been a soldier at all. I guess the filmmakers made him a returning soldier was a subtle message about how war changed people. Mark changed to become a disturbingly cruel person, and his mates was remarkably unashamed about Mark's war crimes. It's a very subtle anti-war message, hidden carefully without being like a propaganda, which is rather unlike the anti war message in "Home Of The Brave".
"In the Valley of Elah" is a powerful film. I liked it a lot.