There is no good reason for this film to get anything below a 7.5. I have loved this film since my childhood, and recently was on the verge of tears during one particular scene.
Perhaps people just don't know what to make of this movie... and they critize it as being kiddie and trite and whatnot... its a KID's MOVIE, for God's sake! Dustin Hoffman and Robin Williams are great in their characterization of Hook and Pan. The beginning of the movie builds great tension with the "After-the-fact" kidnapping - the hook slashes down the hallway build up great suspense. Just...MAN THIS MOVIE IS GREAT!
Like I said before, just pretend this movie is rated "7.5" and go RENT IT! You will love it! Just don't except an all out Spielberg masterpiece, you might be just a little (yes, maybe just a little) disappointed. Otherwise, SIT BACK, ENJOY, and say FU to all the idiots who gave this movie a low rating.